An algorithm for forensic toolmark comparisons
Date
2024-07-24
Authors
Cuellar, Maria
Gao, Sheng
Hofmann, Heike
Major Professor
Advisor
Committee Member
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Elsevier B.V.
Abstract
Forensic toolmark analysis traditionally relies on subjective human judgment, leading to inconsistencies and lack of transparency. The multitude of variables, including angles and directions of mark generation, further complicates comparisons. To address this, we first generate a dataset of 3D toolmarks from various angles and directions using consecutively manufactured slotted screwdrivers. By using PAM clustering, we find that there is clustering by tool rather than angle or direction. Using Known Match and Known Non-Match densities, we establish thresholds for classification. Fitting Beta distributions to the densities, we allow for the derivation of likelihood ratios for new toolmark pairs. With a cross-validated sensitivity of 98 % and specificity of 96 %, our approach enhances the reliability of toolmark analysis. This approach is applicable to slotted screwdrivers, and for screwdrivers that are made with a similar production method. With data collection of other tools and factors, it could be applied to compare toolmarks of other types. This empirically trained, open-source solution offers forensic examiners a standardized means to objectively compare toolmarks, potentially decreasing the number of miscarriages of justice in the legal system.
Series Number
Journal Issue
Is Version Of
Versions
Series
Academic or Administrative Unit
Type
article
Comments
This article is published as Cuellar, Maria, Sheng Gao, and Heike Hofmann. "An algorithm for forensic toolmark comparisons." Forensic Science International: Synergy 9 (2024): 100543. doi:10.1016/j.fsisyn.2024.100543.
Rights Statement
© 2024 The Authors. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/bync-
nd/4.0/).